
What is an adviser’s phone call worth today in the client relationship?
In market downturns, it is advisable for financial advisers to get in touch with clients to explain what is happening and reassure them. Above all, to protect the portfolio, which can be put at risk more by clients’ irrational decisions than by the market
Checking the portfolio takes only a few seconds. Understanding a loss and deciding how to deal with it can be far more difficult. It is at this point that the adviser’s phone call retains its value: listening to concerns, explaining the risks and bringing choices back to personal goals. It is assistance that matters in negative stock market phases, but also in the ordinary management of savings, without every contact having to turn into a sales pitch. We discussed this topic with our economics and finance expert Francesco Megna.
1. In a world where prices, news and portfolios can be checked at any time, what value does the adviser’s phone call add? What can a conversation offer that an app or a written communication cannot?
Information is available to everyone, but interpreting it in relation to one’s own circumstances is another matter. An app shows how much an investment is losing; a conversation helps to understand what that loss means for the client’s goals. A phone call also makes it possible to pick up hesitations, concerns and needs that are hard to detect from a screen. The adviser’s value lies in linking what is happening on the markets to the person’s life, distinguishing a temporary movement from a problem that needs attention. To do so, however, the adviser must know the client and leave room for their questions: a standard explanation, simply read out over the phone, adds little.
2. When markets fall sharply, should it be the adviser who calls first? How do you choose the right moment, avoiding silence that looks like indifference or a call that fuels alarm?
It is advisable for the adviser to take the initiative, especially with clients who are more exposed or who may find a negative phase harder to bear. Always waiting for them to ask risks leaving room for misunderstandings and impulsive decisions. Timeliness, however, must be accompanied by preparation: before calling, you need to know the portfolio’s exposure and have a reliable picture of the situation. Tone also matters. A phone call framed as a normal part of assistance conveys presence; a rushed call may have the opposite effect. Setting out in advance how contact will be maintained during periods of volatility helps ensure that every phone call is not perceived as a sign of an emergency.
3. What should a good phone call contain during a difficult stock market phase? How much space should be devoted to explaining the markets and how much to listening to the client’s personal concerns?
I would start with listening, asking what is worrying the client and whether their needs have changed in the meantime. The fear may concern the loss itself, but also an upcoming expense or a family difficulty of which the adviser is not yet aware. At that point, a clear explanation is needed: what is happening, which parts of the portfolio are affected and what consequences there may be in relation to the agreed goals. There is no need for a lecture on economics. The conversation should end with clear indications of what will be monitored, any checks to be carried out and the next update. Even when no action is taken, the client must understand why.
4. Where is the line between reassuring the client and minimising a real risk? How do you convey confidence without promising recoveries or giving certainties that no one can have?
Reassuring means making the situation understandable, including its unfavourable aspects. Minimising, by contrast, means avoiding the problem with phrases such as “everything will go back to how it was” or “you just have to wait”. Not all investments recover, and not all clients can wait the same amount of time. Trust is built by explaining what we know, what remains uncertain and what tools we have to manage risk. If the portfolio is overly concentrated or no longer consistent with the person’s needs, that must be acknowledged. The adviser is credible when they show a method and a willingness to engage, even in the face of a loss, without turning a possibility of recovery into a promise.
5. How much can a timely phone call influence the client’s decisions? Can it help them avoid a sale driven by fear and, at the same time, bring out concrete reasons to review the portfolio?
It can have a great impact because it creates a moment of reflection between emotion and the transaction. When a person sees their wealth fall, they may feel the urge to do something simply to stop the discomfort. A phone call helps check whether the decision responds to a concrete need or to the fear of the moment. This does not mean persuading the client to keep any investment at all costs. The discussion may reveal a need for liquidity, a lower tolerance for losses than assumed, or an underestimated risk. The best outcome is a reasoned decision, which may consist of keeping the portfolio, changing it or reducing exposure.
6. The same market decline can have very different consequences for different investors. How should the conversation change with a pensioner who uses capital, a family preparing an important expense or a young person with a long horizon ahead?
The conversation must start from the intended use of the money. For a pensioner who supplements their income with wealth, it is necessary to assess the sustainability of withdrawals and the availability of resources for current spending. For a family that has to meet an important purchase, the timing and certainty of the sums required matter above all. A young person may have more time to ride out fluctuations, but that does not mean they can take on any risk: job stability and available reserves must be taken into account. Age alone is not enough. The decisive question is how much that loss could jeopardise a project or force a sale at an unfavourable moment.
7. Outside emergencies, when is it useful to call the client? Which information or changes deserve a direct contact, even when there is no transaction to propose?
The relationship should have continuity even when the markets are calm. A deadline, a significant change in risk or a shift in the conditions of an investment may warrant a phone call. But it is just as useful to check periodically whether personal circumstances have changed: work, family, retirement and spending plans often alter financial needs before prices do. Not every contact should end with an actionable proposal. Knowing that the adviser is also interested in the coherence of the path, without necessarily having something to place, strengthens the quality of the relationship. The frequency and mode of contact should be agreed, respecting the person’s preferences.
8. In banking networks, what conditions allow the adviser to offer this kind of assistance properly? Do the number of clients, available time and work organisation make it possible to maintain personal contact, especially when everyone is asking for attention at once?
Individual availability is not enough if the organisation leaves no time to prepare and follow up conversations. A manageable number of relationships, up-to-date information and tools that reduce administrative work are needed. In difficult moments, priorities must also be set on the basis of clients’ needs, taking into account exposure, liquidity needs and vulnerability, rather than looking only at the wealth entrusted. The network should provide support and continuity even when the adviser is unavailable. Finally, the assessment system matters: if it rewards almost exclusively sales production, assistance risks being sacrificed. The quality of the relationship must have real space in the organisation and in the goals.
9. How is the value of an assistance call measured? Which signs make it possible to understand whether the client has a better grasp of their situation and can make more informed decisions, without simply counting the contacts made?
The number of calls measures an activity, not its outcome. One early sign is the client’s ability to explain, in their own words, which risks they are facing and why a particular choice was agreed. Clear next steps also matter, as does the emergence of information useful for updating the financial plan. Feedback can be gathered on understanding and the usefulness of the contact, as well as checking whether the commitments made have been kept. Even the absence of transactions does not, on its own, prove that the phone call was successful: the client may still have been left confused. The value lies in improving the quality of the decision, not in obtaining obedience or momentary reassurance.
10. Does the phone call remain important even for younger clients used to digital channels? Looking ahead, what place will voice, personal relationships and continuity of assistance have in ever more technologically driven advice?
Being used to digital tools does not eliminate the need for discussion, especially when a decision involves significant savings. Some clients prefer messages or video calls; others only want to speak during the most delicate stages. The channel should be chosen together, avoiding assumptions based on age alone. Technology can make monitoring easier and free up time for assistance, but the relationship retains its value when it allows doubts, responsibilities and personal consequences to be discussed. In the future, continuity will matter most: being able to reach someone who knows one’s situation, remembers previous decisions and is available even when there is no transaction to propose.
Tags
Related articles
Newsletter
The Patrimoni & Finanza newsletter
A considered selection of analysis on economy, Real Estate and wealth
Patrimoni e Finanza — La selezione della settimana: weekly newsletter, sent in Italian
After you submit, if the address can be subscribed you will receive an email with a link to click: the subscription starts only after the click



